| The purpose of
the ignition wire is to deliver all of the energy that the
ignition system can produce from the coil(s) to the spark plug.
An ignition wire can't, in and of itself produce additional
energy. It is merely the conduit for the energy already produced.
The difficulty in delivering all of the energy under all conditions
without causing problems due to Radio Frequency Interference
(RFI) and Electro-mechanical Interference (EMI), is what differentiates
one type or brand of ignition wire from another. The electrical
property that primarily affects this is resistance. In this
case it is the resistance to the flow of electrons (electricity)
and is measured in ohms. When you hear or read of an ignition
wire with 50 ohms of resistance it means 50 ohms per foot.
The perfect ignition wire would have zero ohms resistance and
zero RFI. The problem in producing the perfect wire is that
resistance is inversely proportional to RFI. That is as you
lower the resistance toward zero, it produces more RFI. The
ideal situation is to have the lowest resistance wire while
keeping RFI below levels that would cause problems with computerized
engine controls (SAE has specifications for this) and without
violating FCC regulations. We will now explain the various
constructions of ignition wire to help you make an informed
decision for your particular application.
Conductors
There are three basic designs of ignition conductor with variations
of each. This will describe each of the conductors and provide
an understanding of how each will function in a particular
application.
Copper: The very first ignition conductors were made
of copper and were used exclusively for almost sixty years.
At the time they were the ideal choice because they had almost
no resistance to the flow of electricity and the conductor
would last beyond the life of the engine. Then in the 1960's
the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) issued regulations
that limited the amount of RFI that could emanate from a source,
mainly the automobile. The older generation may remember "hearing" a
cars engine over their radios and televisions. The copper conductors
gave off far too much RFI to be compatible with a world that
was becoming "wireless" with its communication devices. For
these reasons copper is rarely used on automotive or marine
engines. The exception to this is a few European car manufacturers
that use the copper conductor but install a resistor, usually
5000 ohms, at the spark plug boot. Copper was an excellent
choice years ago but, for the most part, is no longer the best
choice.
Carbon: Today the most widely used conductor is carbon-impregnated
latex which is applied over Kevlar® or fiberglass. It is
often referred to as "suppression" conductor because of its
RFI suppression properties. It is used by virtually all of
the original equipment and aftermarket wire set producers.
This conductor has two distinct advantages; it has excellent
RFI suppression and is relatively inexpensive. However as in
most things, there is a downside. The carbon conductor relies
on microscopic carbon particles touching each other in order
to efficiently conduct electricity. Any movement of the wire,
whether through handling or engine vibration, causes the carbon
particles to move apart. When they do, the flow of electrons
through the particles causes them to polarize and act like
little magnets. As we learned in grade school, opposites attract
and like charges repel. The carbon particles that "face" each
other with the same charge (positive or negative) "push" each
other apart causing a breakdown in the flow of the electrons.
When enough of them react like this the wire breaks down, that
is, the electrons stop flowing or they find a shorter path
to ground - usually the engine block. When this happens the
engine misfires.
Another issue with carbon wires is the effect its "good" property,
resistance, has on the insulation encasing the conductor. As
the resistance increases, some of the energy being "used" is
converted from electrical energy to heat energy. (The reason
a light bulb gets hot is because the filament is a resistor
that converts the electrical energy to light and heat .) When
enough of this internally generated heat combines with the
external heat from the engine compartment, it can lead to the
premature failure of the insulation, which lets the spark jump
to the nearest ground instead of across the spark plug gap.
It may even lead to a burn out of the conductor itself, particularly
where it is folded back to attach to the terminal at the spark
plug end of the wire. There are carbon conductors made with
a thin extrusion of silicon over them to help alleviate this
problem however they are more expensive. The additional expense
eliminates most of the price benefit of the carbon conductor.
Due to the above issues a carbon conductor begins to deteriorate
from the first moment that it conducts electricity. The initial
resistance is from 3000 ohms to 7000 ohms per foot. This gradually
increases until it fails. Failure normally takes place between
15,000 and 50,000 miles. Carbon conductor is a good choice
when price is a primary concern. It will perform very well
in most applications. It is not a good choice if consistent
performance or longevity is an issue.
Wire Wound: Often referred to as "Magwire" or spiral
wound, wire wound conductors have a carbon core conductor that
is wound with a thin thread of a metal wire, usually stainless
steel or a copper-nickel alloy. This gives it the low resistance
advantage of the copper conductor but also give it the RFI
suppression advantage of the copper conductor. Wire wound,
unlike carbon conductor, is not affected by internal heat and
its resistance remains constant instead of gradually getting
higher. Wire wound conductors generally have a resistance range
from 350 to 1500 ohms per foot. With the advent of OBDII having
the engine's computer record minor misfires and with car manufacturers
trying to meet the requirements of their emissions warranties,
some original equipment manufacturers are switching form carbon
core to wire wound.
In the past few years a new construction of wire wound conductor
was developed. The "reactive" wire wound conductor has ferrite-impregnated
latex instead of the carbon center and is wound with a copper-nickel
alloy instead of stainless steel. The "reactance" this creates
allow us to get resistance as low as 25 ohms per foot while
still suppressing the RFI.
As you can see from the last two paragraphs, wire wound is
superior to the carbon conductor. The only disadvantage is
price and the lower the resistance the higher the price. The
regular wire wound conductor is about twice as expensive as
the carbon conductor. The reactive wire wound conductor can
be, depending on how low the resistance is, ten times as expensive
as the carbon conductor. In summation, the wire wound conductor
is the best choice if longevity, consistency and low resistance
outweigh the price advantage of carbon core.
Other Factors Affecting Conductors: Electromagnetic
Interference (EMI) is similar to RFI in the problems it causes
however it acts differently. EMI is produced by the flow of
electrons through a conductor creating a magnetic field. This
field actually extends outside of the insulation of the wire.
Unlike RFI, which can affect devices hundreds of feet away,
EMI only affects devices in close proximity to the wire. This
causes problems if the wires are routed too close to a sensor
or the ECM. It will also cause a problem when the ignition
wires are run for a long distance in parallel. The EMI can
actually induce current flow in the wire running alongside
it thereby creating a misfire. It is important to either closely
follow the original routing of the wires or check or be sure
they "cross" if two wires are running together for more than
a foot or so.
Corona Effect : Corona Effect
is a phenomenon which may be observed when viewing an engine
running at night with the hood up. This phenomenon appears
as a greenish blue halo around the wires. The amount of corona
is dependent mainly on the humidity of the air and the amount
of voltage pushing the electrons through the conductor. As
the voltage and/or humidity increase, a more pronounced corona
is observed. Be aware that it does not cause any problems.
It is normal and there is absolutely nothing wrong with
the wires. An actual arcing of a spark to ground does
indicate a problem. A spark going to ground will make a noise,
corona does not make noise.
Ignition Wire Jacketing There are seven materials commonly used for ignition wire
jacketing. Please see the ensuing chart for a comparison of
the materials:
The compounds in the chart are ranked from best to worst for
ignition wire applications with Silicone being the best. The
two most important factors in the chart are Heat Resistance
and Insulating Properties. At the bottom end, PVC should never
be used for ignition wire but some extruders use it for a very
low cost ignition wire. It is "plastic" and can melt at temperatures
as low as 130 degrees. In a double extruded ignition wire,
the above are also used as the "first pass" insulation over
the conductor. For the best ignition wire set, without regard
to price, always look for dual silicone jackets - especially
in a high heat condition.
Ignition Wire Compound Comparison
Jacket |
Heat |
Insulating |
Resistance
to |
Resistance |
Relative |
Material |
Resistance |
Properties |
|
to
Tearing |
Cost |
|
(Degrees
F) |
(Dielectric
Strength) |
Gasoline,
Oil, and Antifreeze |
|
1
= Highest |
Silicone |
500 |
Excellent |
Average |
Average |
1 |
EPS |
375 |
Very Good |
Above Average |
Above Average |
2 |
EVA |
325 |
Average |
Average |
Excellent |
3 |
EPDM |
350 |
Above Average |
Above Average |
Above Average |
4 |
Hypalon |
300 |
Average |
Above Average |
Average |
5 |
Neoprene |
250 |
Below Average |
Below Average |
Average |
6 |
PVC |
200 |
Excellent |
Above Average |
Excellent |
7 |
Ignition Terminals
Types: Ignition terminals come in various styles
and materials. Terminals that attach to the spark plug or the
SAE style (male stud) of the distributor cap or coil are either
non-snap or snap lock terminals. There is no question that
only snap lock terminals should be used. Non-snap lock terminals
do not lock onto the plug securely and can even cause Radio
Frequency Interference. The difference in cost is about a penny
per terminal, certainly not enough to compensate for the possible
problems they can cause. While it is obvious that a snap lock
terminal should be used, it gets more complicated when we look
at the different types of snap lock terminals. Probably more
than 90 percent of all snap lock terminals are made of zinc
plated steel. Zinc plating is perfectly acceptable for most
applications. If, however, there is any possibility of extended
exposure to salt air, there could be problems. Zinc is even
used as a sacrificial anode on boats because the salt will
eat away at the zinc and leave other metals relatively untouched.
Fortunately stainless steel terminals are available from a
few high quality terminal manufacturers like ETCO of Bradenton,
Florida. Certainly all marine craft used in or near salt water
and all vehicles kept in coastal areas should have stainless
steel terminals. Unfortunately, almost no marine engine manufacturer
other than Pleasurecraft/Crusader and Marine Power uses stainless
terminals. There are two after-market marine wire set manufacturers
that use stainless terminals and they are branded under
Marine and Aqua Power. One other condition, often ignored,
where stainless steel terminals are needed is in States that
use road salt to melt ice. Once again, we haven't found many
OE car manufacturers using stainless terminals. One company
that uses only stainless terminals in their high performance
wire sets is Vitek Performance in Atlanta , GA.
Spark Plug Boots
Types: There are two primary
types of spark plug boots; the one-piece boot, and the three-piece
boot assembly usually found on overhead cam engines. Since
the greatest amount of heat that the ignition wire set has
to contend with is usually at the spark plug, a material that
will withstand temperatures in excess of about 340 degrees
F is necessary. We recommend that all spark plug boots be made
of silicone to avoid any problems. EPDM is an acceptable substitute
in many applications where cost is a factor. The three-piece
boot assembly consists of a top boot, phenolic tube, and a
tip seal. It is important that quality phenolic tubes are used
as they can have dielectric problems similar to those experienced
by distributor caps and rotors. If there are any signs of carbon
tracking on a set in use, it should be replaced. In addition,
any wire set assembler should run batch tests requiring new
phenolic tubes to pass a dielectric test in excess of 40,000
volts. We recommend that the top boot and tip seal be made
of silicone.
Distributor / Coil Boots
Types: Distributor boots and coil boots
are not subjected to the amount of heat that a spark plug boot
is. For this reason, silicone is not needed at that end of
the wire but they should be made of EPDM or a material with
similar properties.
Dielectric Gel
A silicone dielectric (non-conductive) gel should be applied
inside of the spark plug boot, preferably a silicone gel with
Teflon added. This serves three purposes:
- It helps seal the
boot thereby preventing moisture from traveling onto the
spark plugs ceramic insulator.
- It lubricates the spark
plug boot allowing for easier removal when necessary.
- It "fills in" tiny spaces between
the terminal and the spark plug connector helping to eliminate
a possible source of RFI caused by terminal vibration.
- The application of dielectric gel is so critical that
Vitek voids the
warranty on any set where the dielectric
gel was not used.
Other Issues
There are a number of good quality wire sets on the market
and many companies will have more than one level or quality
of product. The high performance manufacturers tend to use
better materials in the construction of their products than
Original Equipment or some Aftermarket companies, however don't
be fooled by some so called high performance wire sets that
claim to improve performance by using multiple conductors (absolutely
no benefit), metal shielding for a capacitive effect (we haven't
been able to measure any benefit on test equipment with them),
or anything else that sounds "gimmicky".
Summary
In order to help you with your choice, these are the facts
and the very best ignition wire sets will have the following
in common:
- A low resistance wire wound (Magwire), reactive
core conductor
- A silicone outer jacket
- Stainless Steel ignition terminals
- Silicon spark plug
boots
If the wire set you choose has all four of these features,
you can be sure that you are purchasing a very high quality
wire set that should perform well under extreme conditions.
In addition, sets made with these materials should last indefinitely.
The Vitek Performance Solution
Vitek High Performance and Vitek Ultra Series ignition wires
address all of these performance challenges. Vitek begins with
an extremely durable multi-strand braided KevlarT core with
a micro-wound stainless steel conductor and a highly conductive
ferrite impregnated material for superior current characteristics.
To maximize EMI/RFI suppression, Vitek High Performance ignition
wires are encased in a pure, high temperature silicone jacket.
That is where most wire manufactures end their construction.
Vitek then applies a strengthening layer of braided fiberglass
and an additional jacket of more pure silicone for the best
suppression and durability in the marketplace. The Vitek Ultra
Series ignition wires take ignition wire construction to the
next level with an exclusive super high temperature resistant
braided fiberglass jacket for the most extreme performance
environments. Both series of wires are available in extremely
low resistance racing configurations.
Our Original Equipment Series spark plug wires are
a value priced solution that address the issues mentioned above
as well. Manufactured with our unique stainless steel wire
wound ("Mag Wire") conductor with a Dupont Kevlar Ò core
for superior pull strength. The conductor is insulated with
an extrusion of pure gold silicone then braided with fiberglass
to achieve ultimate mechanical strength of the finished product.
The wire goes through a second extrusion of pure silicone to
a finished diameter of 6mm, 8mm, or 9mm depending on the original
equipment requirements. The Series OE ignition wire
is rated at 850 ohm per foot.
|